Off Topic / Re: Do not buy food raised by slaves- it is always nutrient-poor!
« on: April 15, 2015, 07:58:23 pm »They are not slaves in the literal sense of the word, but they are definitely not granted their basic worker's rights and human rights!
There's no such thing as worker's rights. You don't get special rights just for being a worker. There are only human rights, and they are the rights to own property, including one's own bodies, and to not have their property aggressed upon by others. And these rights haven't been breached here. Nobody has a right to good working conditions, or to have a job in the first place. If they don't like their jobs, they shouldn't take them, or they should quit.
It's not that simple when you're a migrant that doesn't have any other option than to either stick to the only available shitty job, or pay some more money -that they usually don't have- to go back to their country of origin. They are pretty much stuck here, and their employers know it very well.
Nobody forced them to be migrant workers. They chose to do that out of their own wills. And what's more, that's not the employer's problem or their responsibility to fix. If someone would starve if you don't give them a job, does that make you responsible for hiring them? No. It's their responsiblity to find their own means of subsistence that don't involve committing crimes against others. If you still want to help them, that's perfectly fine. But you shouldn't be compelled to by law.
What other word than "slave" would you use to describe them? "exploited laborer" is perhaps more accurate...
Workers.
And what do you mean by exploited? Everybody is exploited. Exploitation means putting some resource to use. You are exploiting me by reading my posts, and I'm exploiting you. The workers are exploiting the employers to get jobs that will pay them, in their view, better money and with better working conditions than they were able to get in their own countries. We know this because they chose to move there and stay there with all the complications that implies, just so that they could have those jobs.
Well that's a very lousy strategy then since a simple investigation will show that the workers lied.
I didn't say they lied. It could all be true and it would still be extortion. And of course, if they don't want the jobs anymore, it doesn't cost them anything to make up lies. The only valid complain is the one where they said they're only being paid for 16 days even though they worked 26, which I doubt. And the part about pesticides would only be valid if they were told they wouldn't be sprayed with them. If they were aware of what was going on and they chose to keep the job, it's their responsibility if they got sick.
And I think it's safe to say that Spanish field owners have more influence on the state's opinion than a bunch of non-native salad pickers.
That could very well be true, but that's not the point.